After an emotional day with Greg’s family, showing Katie photos of his late father, Greg decides to be honest with Katie about the fact that he “lost part of himself” when his father passed away. .
“I didn’t know I’d fall in love with you,” she continued. “I didn’t know that, and I love you. And you make me the happiest I’ve ever been, and I see it with you.”
But Greg’s mood changed shortly after that moment. He wasn’t appreciative of Katie’s reaction, as she smiled and told her, “I just love seeing you,” and also told her that he would get a rose but didn’t hint much at his feelings. During the first episode, she explained to the families that she had decided who she was falling in love with until it was the last man.
Katie picks up on Greg’s change in mood, saying that she can tell he’s “not happy right now” and that they had a tense conversation when he took her to the car. “I just don’t understand how you don’t know…that it’s me and you at the moment,” he told her. “I’ve never emptied my heart for someone like this before.”