As the drama aired, Evan posted a GIF on his Instagram Story shaking his head at the show, adding the message, “That’s the way @bachelorinparadise is going tonight.”
During the episode, Ivan also retweeted “Whoever gets my first Post Paradise podcast interview is going to get some gold,” he said in his own tweet from last week. He added the note in the retweet, “Can’t wait for it right now.”
It all happened after viewers saw Aaron and Evan exchanging threats earlier in the day while they were competing for Chelsea’s love. Aaron was upset that Evan and Chelsea told People he wouldn’t try to take anyone’s rose, but Evan firmly claimed that Chelsea had asked to speak to him.
Then, Chelsea got wind of the situation and confirmed that it was indeed Evan who asked her to share a one-on-one time, leading many cast members to refer to her as a liar.